Is Honors Useless? Or is it Inflated?

The Honors B-Grade Versus the Regular A.

Today, we present a debate stemming from the age-old question: Is it better to get an "A" in a regular class or a "B" in an Honors class? Consider the complexities of academic achievement and college admissions as our readers (Anonymous) and Ryan Chen dissect the nuances of academic rigor and personal growth. Holding different standpoints, they discuss whether aiming for excellence in challenging courses outweighs the security of achieving top grades in standard classes. Indeed, we have for you a transcript of their conversation and, we must say, it gets quite heated. So, please sit back, grab some popcorn, and get ready for a showdown.

(Anonymous) "Benefits Advocate" : Honors classes can be a game-changer. The deeper understanding, the critical thinking skills, the competitive edge – these are all invaluable benefits that can propel students to academic greatness. Sure, it may require extra effort, but the rewards are well worth it.

Ryan "Costs Considerer" Chen: I'm sorry, hold up. Let's not overlook the potential downsides of honors classes. The stress, the pressure, the impact on mental well-being – these are real concerns that can't be brushed aside. While honors classes may offer academic challenges, the risks to mental health and overall academic performance are significant factors that shouldn't be ignored.

(Anonymous): Sorry, Ryan, but it seems like you're just focused on the negatives. Students who are willing to work hard and push themselves will see the benefits of honors classes. Those who can't handle the pressure should just stick to the standard curriculum. It's survival of the fittest in the academic world.

Ryan: Okay, that's a pretty harsh stance, and I really don't think it's warranted. We need to consider the well-being of students as a top priority, not just academic success at all costs. Honors classes can provide valuable opportunities, but it's essential to find a balance and ensure that students are not overwhelmed by the demands placed on them.

What I mean is that honors classes offer unique advantages in terms of academic growth, critical thinking skills, and college readiness. But you also have to consider the limits of the student. The decision to enroll in these courses should involve a consideration of both the benefits and potential risks, and finding a balance between academic challenge and well-being is essential for any student, dedicated or not.

While (Anonymous) and Ryan may have not fully agreed (or agreed at all) on the necessity of honors courses, we at The Wave think they both made valuable points. For this reason, we have pulled some statistics and writings from other resources, to give you the full scoop on both claims:

What's the Difference?

Here's a chart from CollegeVine (thanks, guys) that explains the translation of grade and GPA between regular and honors classes:

"It depends on your high school, but most schools weigh honors classes an additional 0.5 points. That means that if you get a B+ in Honors Geometry, normally a 3.3, it would translate to a 3.8 in your GPA calculations. AP and IB courses are typically weighted by a full point. However, your unweighted GPA will not be affected by honors courses. "

Should I Take Honors?

As best said by Laura Berlinsky-Schine, "Ultimately, if you think you can get at least a B in an honors class without taxing yourself, you should probably go for it over the regular version. This will help colleges see that you’re willing to take on a challenge, even if it’s not in your area of expertise. Likewise, if you think you can get a B in an AP/IB class, it may be worth taking, especially since you can earn college credit or place out of the introductory course by taking the exams. 

But if you’re not sure you’ll be able to earn at least a B, then go for the regular level. Or, if the class isn’t in one of your core subjects, then consider replacing it with an elective — one in a stronger area."

Thanks guys. We hope we made your choice a bit easier.

-The Wave Writing Team

pssst... hey. You can join our community of student, teacher, and parent writers – do you know why? Because your voice matters to us! Share your stories and perspectives with us and be part of our publication. We will publish your article, once reviewed. Long-term participants (100 hours+) are eligible for exclusive benefits, including a pin and signed letter from the President of the United States. For more information on how to become a contributor and details on our asset program, visit our The Wave Asset Program on our website today.